top of page

Isabella de Medici (1542 - 1576)

Isabella Romola de Medici (31 August 1542 - 16 July 1576) was the daughter of Cosimo I de Medici, first Grand Duke of Tuscany,  and Eleonora di Toledo.

The marriage of Cosimo and Eleonora took place by proxy in Naples on 29 March 1539. Eleonora became pregnant soon after her wedding night, and on 3 April 1540, a little girl was born to her and Cosimo. They named her Maria, the name of both Cosimo and Eleonor's morthers. The following year saw the birth of Francesco, on 25 March 1541. Cosimo now had a son, to be known as Il Principe, the prince, in deference to his status as heir apparent. Eleonora had done what no Medici wife had done in more than half a century: she had produced a legitimate male heir. When she became pregnant for the third time at the end of that year, she felt sure she was carrying a boy again, her severe morning sickness confirming her belief in the opinion of others, if not that of her husband. On 31 August 1542, Eleonora delivered her baby.

The couple gave their daughter the names Isabella, after Eleonora's sister, and Romola, the feminine of Romolo, tha patron saint of Fiesole. But Isabella was to be more than just a younger daughter. Five months before her birth, on 1 March 1542, Cosimo's illegitimate daughter Bia, died, aged about six years old. While he might have discarded her unknown mother long ago, Bia had been very precious to Cosimo. For Cosimo, if Isabella, born so soon after Bia's death, was not the reincarnation of the daughter he had recently lost, she was to be the recipient of all the love he had once given to Bia.

Isabella did not remain the youngest for long. A second  son, Giovanni, named after Cosimo's father, arrived just thirteen months after Isabella, meaning that Eleonora had thus far produced a child for every year. Then there was a lag of two years, before the birth of Lucrezia in 1545. After Lucrezia's birth, only three of the six children survived infanthood: Garzia, born in 1547, Ferdinando and Pietro, born in 1549 and 1554 respectively.

It was Maria Salviati who took care of Isabella from the moment she was born, nursing her through her illness and reporting on her well-being in the same affectionate terms as she had with her first grandchild, Bia.

But Maria would not be able to protect her grandchildren for much longer. In fact, Isabella would be the last Maria would be able to care for. In 1541, when Maria was forty-two years old, the court doctors began to send regular reports to Cosimo that she was experiencing bouts of rectal bleeding. However, Maria was hesitant to have such an intimate part of her body examined by a doctor. Her condition worsened and two years later Maria was being afflicted by frequent evacuation of 'watery blood'. She was continuously feverish, she could not sleep and she could not keep food down. She died at Castello on 12 December 1543.

The Medici children were not apart from their parents all of the time, and indeed spent more time with the duke and duchess following the death of their grandmother. Sometimes their parents joined them at Castello. Isabella and her siblings also sometimes joined their parents at one of the Medici country villas in relatively close reach of the city, such as at Careggi, in the hills behind Fiesole, at La Petraia, on the road to Bologna. On occasion they even made the long journey with their parents to Pisa, a distant outpost of Cosimo's duchy, but it was important he visit it in order to maintain it within his control.

The Medici brood lived first in the Palazzo Vecchio and later in the Palazzo Pitti, spending much of their time at their father's ancestral country home, Castello. Because they spent so much time in the country, they engaged from an early age in all kinds of sport: hunting, fishing and horse riding, which they learned almost as infants. Other physical activities included dancing, an essential part of a young Medici's training for courtly activities, receptions and balls.

The Medici children had a movable schoolroom, set up whetever they were in residence. Some of the children were more able pupils than others. Isabella herself was multilingual with Spanish, French, Latin and Greek; she became very keen on the precise speaking and writing of Tuscan. From an early age Isabella showed a great love for music, which in her adulthood she used as means for self-expression.

Eleonora di Toledo by Agnolo Bronzino, about 1543

Cosimo I de Medici by Agnolo Bronzino, about 1545

Maria Salviati by Agnolo Bronzino, about 1543

Isabella de Medici by Agnolo Bronzino, around 1550

Lucrezia de Medici by Alessandro Allori, around 1560

Isabella de Medici by Agnolo Bronzino, around 1558

Isabella de Medici in her mid-twenties,

by Alessandro Allori

Giovanni de Medici by Agnolo Bronzino

Troilo Orsini became not simply Isabella's lover; he became, as much as was possible, the replacement for the role her brother Giovanni had once fulfilled. That reason perhaps explains why Cosimo allowed his daughter this relationship, he being the only one who had the power to put a stop to it.

In December 1565, a new addition to the Medici family arrived in the form of a bride for Francesco: seventeen-year-old Joanna of Austria. Her status was an indication of the degree to which the Medici star had ascended during Cosimo's reign. Alessandro de Medici, had been married to Margaret, an illegitimate daughter of the Emperor Charles V. But now Cosimo's son was taking a legitimately born bride, the sister of the Emperor Maximilian II.

However, from the start of their marriage, Francesco made it very plain he had little interest in her beyond her ability to produce children, an issue called into question by her 'very thin  and small stature... for this respect there is the suspicion she is not well adapted for conceiving.'

Joanna of Austria by Alessandro Allori (about 1570)

Francesco I de Medici

It was now time to consider the contribution his eldest children could make to the Medici regime. Francesco's path was the clearest cut. He was son and heir, destined one day to rule in place of his father. In May 1550 Cosimo had contrived to arrange for his younger son, Giovanni, not yet six and a half, to obtain the Archbishopric of Pisa, along with all its attendant benefits. For Maria, his oldest daughter, Cosimo chose to betroth her to Alfonso, the son and heir of Duke Ercole d'Este of Ferrara. The Medici and the d'Este were to some degree rivals. Nonetheless, a matrimonial alliance could serve the political interests of the two families on both the national and international stages, one which would allow Ferrara and Florence to appear united, even if that was not actually the case.

In 1553, at age almost eleven Isabella was betrothed to twelve-year-old Paolo Giordano Orsini, in line for the Duchy of Bracciano in southern Tuscany, a liaison Cosimo felt necessary to secure his southern border and his relationship with the ancient Roman Orsini family. Paolo Giordano's father was Girolamo Orsini, son to Gian Giordano and Felice della Rovere, the illegitimate daughter of Pope Julius II.

The summer and early autumn of 1558 was to be the season for the weddings of the Medici princesses. However, Isabella's elder sister Maria, betrothed to Alfonso d'Este of Ferrara, was not destined to be a bride. She died from malaria on 19 November 1557, aged seventeen. However, paternal grief notwithstanding, Cosimo could not afford to let the opportunity of a marriage to the future Duke of Ferrara pass the Medici by. He entered into negotiations with Ercole d'Este, for his son Alfonso to take, in Maria's place, Cosimo's third daughter, twelve-year-old Lucrezia, a substitution Ercole and Alfonso were willing to accept. The families had a marriage contract drawn uo by April 1558, and Alfonso arrived in Florence on 19 June. The marriage between Alfonso and Lucrezia took place on 3 July, the wedding Mass being celebrated in the chapel in the Palazzo Vecchio.

On 3 September, the Medici gathered at the villa at Poggio a Caiano, the air perfumed by the ripening of the fruits on the trees planted in Poggio's grounds. They listened to words and music composed to welcome the Orsini into the Medici family, a reversal of the norm in which it was the bride who was welcomed into her husband's family.

Cosimo had decided that Isabella was not to take up a residence in Rome with Paolo. He decreed that Paolo would live by himself in Rome and would come to Florence when he wished to see his wife. Cosimo's decision was partly financial, for if Isabella left Florence, and her dowry went with her, Cosimo would be placing her fiscal well-being in the hands of Paolo, whom he did not trust to make wise decisions, concerned by the spending habits of his new son-in-law, Yet his desire for Isabella to remain in Florence was not solely a monetary issue.

After Paolo's departure on 4 September 1558, Isabella's life went on very much as it had done before. She continued to live alongside her siblings, including Lucrezia, who did not move to Ferrara until February 1560, for her husband Alfonso d'Este was fighting in France.

Since making Giovanni de Medici a cardinal, Pope Pius IV had bestowed even more honours on his family. In October 1560, the Pope gave Cosimo's third son Garzia the title of Commander of the Papal Fleet. Given that Garzia was thirteen-year-old youth, nobody had any intention of sending him away to sea, but the income accompanied the position which the Medici family would find useful. Moreover, if the eldest son would one day be ruler of Florence and the second a cardinal, it made sense to put the third on the path to a military career.

In April 1561 news arrived from Ferrara which struck a blow to Cosimo's carefully planned strategies to secure external alliances. His daughter Lucrezia had been ailing for about a month. Her symptoms - fevers, severe weight loss, constant coughing and a bleeding nose - have led to a modern diagnosis that Lucrezia was suffering from tuberculosis. On the night of 21 April she was dead and there had been no children resulting from her marriage to Alfonso d'Este.

Cosimo's eldest son Francesco did trouble him. At the age of twenty, Francesco was still prone to the bouts of melancholy, gloominess and antisocial behaviour he had exhibited as a child, which hardly made him the best of company. These qualities were now combined with a lack of attention to the duties of prince, excessive spending and an unnecessary entourage. Francesco felt injured by his father's attitude towards him and was certain that his place by his father's affections ranked below that of his sister Isabella and brother Giovanni. Certainly their characters and temperaments made for more harmonious company, but Francesco seemed to avoid them both, rarely joining them or the rest of his family.

Isabella was often in the company of her brother Giovanni, who did not like being apart from his sister for too long. Just as the circumstances of Paolo and Isabella's marriage were unusual, so was the adult relationship which evolved between Isabella and her brother. It might be said that Isabella had more of a marriage with Giovanni than she did with Paolo. She spent more time with him and the bond between them, forged in blood and in real love, was far deeper than the one Isabella had with Paolo. Practically twins in terms of age, neither could remember a time without the other, and the longest they had ever been separatd was during Giovanni's three-month trip to Rome the previous year.

Giovanni and Isabella spent the summer of 1562 in very much the same way as they passed the previous year's. They moved from villa to villa to escape the heat, seeking out whatever sport they might have together. Later Giovanni was obliged to leave on business soon after. Cosimo wanted his son, as Archbishop of Pisa, to accompany him on an inspection of the towns of the Maremma coast. Eleonora and her younger sons Garzia and Ferdinando were also part of the party.

On Sunday, 15 November 1562, Giovanni was at the small town of Rosignano, having gone hunting on the wooded coastline. He began to feel that he had a fever, but he decided not to say anything about it and rode on to Livorno the following day to join his parents and two brothers. On Tuesday morning, the family was due to return to Pisa, only Giovanni's fever had grown worse, to the extent the he could not get out of bed. On the night of Friday, 20 November, having received the last rites Giovanni de Medici died in his father's arms.

But tragedy for the Medici family was not at the end. Cosimo concluded his letter to Francesco by telling him that his brothers, fifteen-year-old Garzia and thirteen-year-old Ferdinando, were also suffering from a fever. Although the younger Ferdinando did begin to make a recovery, Garzia grew worse. On 12 December came the report that Garzia de Medici has gone to a better life.

The combination of her own burgeoning malarial fever, tuberculosis and the mental anguish she was suffering after the deaths of Giovanni and Garzia were too much for Eleonora. She lost the will to live and on 17 December, Eleonora di Toledo died, at three in the morning.

The responsibilities of ruling a dukedom denied Cosimo the option of loosing himself in grief that Isabella did in the aftermath of Giovanni's death. For Cosimo, Giovanni's demise meant not only the loss of a beloved son but the loss of the only Medici cardinal. Cosimo was determined to see the position restored to the family as quickly as possible. On 23 December, less than a week after the death of Eleonora, he began negotiating with Pope Pius IV to have the cardinalate transferred to his thirteen-year-old son Ferdinando, who, recovered from the malaria that had claimed his brothers' lives, was now the second eldest Medici boy. Exactly two weeks later, on 6 January 1563, the Pope had complied with Cosimo's request, the remarkable rapidity of the conferral on so young a candidate perceived as a gesture of sympathy on the part of the duke's papal ally.

​Isabella was now by default the first lady of Florence, and consequently her favour and goodwill were highly desirable. One family member who seemed less than enthused about Isabella's own advancement in the family hierarchy was her brother Francesco. He appeared to envision Isabella as a kind of governess, retreating into the nursery the way his mother has done during her last years. But surrogate motherhood was not a role to which his sister took readily, nor does it seem to be one that, contrary to her brother's expectations, her father intended Isabella to fulfil.

​That was no question that Paolo Giordano Orsini was the most privileged member of his vast clan. Although he was unable to live within it, he had a guaranteed income from the vast estates that he controlled. He received benefits from individuals such the king of Spain, without actually having to do anything. Life was not so easy for the majority of his Orsini relations. None had an estate anything like the size of the one Paolo Giordano ruled and all needed supplementary income. A few entered the church, but the majority, if they wanted to make money as soldiers, had to actually go to war and fight. No Orsini of his generation was more determined to succeed on his own merits than Troilo Orsini, who was the same age as his cousin Paolo. One of the first things that many noticed about Troilo was his good looks. 'He was a man who was elegant in all his endeavours, extremely handsome, a great entertainer, a true courtier, the friend of all the ladies and gentlemen' was a contemporary summary of Troilo.

His interest in Isabella already ran deep in the months after her brother Giovanni's death. Her influence with her father aside, she was the 'star of the Medici court', the wittiest, most vivacious woman in Florence, an object of desire in her own right.

Now that Cosimo was a bit older, Isabella began to spend more time with Cardinal Ferdinando when he came up to Florence. Ferdinando's life as a cardinal was somewhat different from that of his predecessor Giovanni in that, although he was no more religious than his brother, Ferdinando spent a lot more time in Rome from an early age. Rome allowed him centre stage far more than did Florence, which was dominated by his father and his elder brother and sister. Ferdinando had better social skills than Francesco, being more willing to appear to be on good terms with everybody, although he seems to have had difficulty concealing his feelings about Paolo Giordano.

Other family members with whom Isabella got on well were her mother's brothers Luigi and Garzia Alvarez di Toledo. Luigi, now Lieutenant of the Kingdom of Naples, like Isabella had deep-running intellectual interests and had spent time in Florence when she was child while earning his doctorate at the University of Pisa, the duchy of Tuscany's primary seat of learning. He had later served as Cosimo's Procurator, formally receiving in Cosimo's name the city of Siena after the Medici victory. Garzia, five years older than Cosimo and appointed Viceroy of Sicily in 1565, was one of Spain's most admired military men, the naval commander-in-chief. It was part due to his military career that he was persuaded, following the death of his wife, to leave his baby daughter in the care fo her aunt Eleonora in Florence. The little girl, also named Eleonora, was sometimes called 'Dianora' as a pet name to avoid any confusion, but came more commonly to be called Leonora.

Leonora was born in 1553 and spent her infancy very much in the background of Medici court life. As she passed out of childhood, it was evident that she possessed considerable charm. She was extremely pretty: her portraits show a fawn-like redhead, with huge dark eyes. Leonora was also extolled as gracious and genteel, charming and affable.

Isabella had not been especially interested in the infant Leonora, who at the age of five liked to attach herself to Isabella's younger sister Lucrezia. But she did later take the blossoming Leonora under her wing. Leonora saw Isabella as her role model and engaged in the same kinds of intellectual activities, music and sports.

Cosimo was also extremely fond of Leonora, to the extent that he had no desire to see her leave Florence, which was set to happen if her father Garzia found her a husband from elsewhere in Italy or Spain. So Cosimo decided to pre-empt Garzia by arranging, in 1568, a betrothal for Leonora to his son Pietro, who was a year younger than his fiancee. Cosimo was also attempting to ensure that his son would receive wife who had grown accustomed to his aberrations. Pietro had what would now be called learning difficulties: he was short-tempered and violent.

One result of the betrothal between Leonora and Pietro and realization that Leonora was in Florence to stay, was that the bond between Isabella and Leonora grew stronger. The pair became closer as Leonora reached maturity and she participated in her cousin's more adult-centric activities. Isabella had not been especially close to her own sisters, but Leonora was to become like a younger sister to her.

By September 1566, Joanna was able to announce that she was three months pregnant; in February 1567 she delivered a baby girl, who became yet another Eleonora to add to the household. Joanna produced two more girls in succesive years, but neither lived more than a few months. She had thus far disappointed Francesco in not bearing any sons. His feelings towards his daughters were limited. But although he was displeased at the lack of a male heir, at least his wife was having children, something that Isabella was not.

As the 1560s progressed, the issue of Isabella and the bearing of children was one clouded in mystery. Her ability to become pregnant had been proved by the miscarriages she had undergone in 1561 and 1562, but no concrete reports of pregnancy had been reported since that time.

In 1569 Pope Pius V elevated Cosimo to the rank of Grand Duke of Tuscany. This title, however, was not recognized by the Habsburg powers or by the other Italian duchies. To gratify the Pope, Cosimo in 1570 married Camilla Martelli, who had long been his mistress. Born into one of the most important families of the Florentine patricians, Camilla was the daughter of Antonio Martelli and Elisabetta Soderini. After the death of Cosimo's first wife Eleonora di Toledo and after the end of his relationship with Eleonora of Albizi, Camilla became Cosimo's lover despite being 26 years his junior.

Cosimo's children Francesco, Isabella and Ferdinando all reeled in disbelief at the news that their father had taken a new bride. After meeting with his father, Francesco reportedly left the room in tears, so humiliated was he that Cosimo,  Grand Duke of Tuscany, had married a woman from the less distinguished Florentine families.

While Isabella was prepared to accept that Camilla be a part of the family if it made her father happy, Joanna used her authority as a Habsburg princess to ensure she was denied a part in Medici public life. Unfortunately for Joanna, Cosimo marrying his mistress was to be a comparatively minor humiliation she was to suffer at the hands of the Medici men, and it was not long before she would come to regret isolating herself from her father-in-law.

It did not take very long for the scandal Camilla Martelli had generated to die down, both in Florence and beyond. Cosimo lived very quitely with his new wife, so it was fairly hard for outrage and gossip to be generated by a woman who was so rarely seen in public. Moreover, as 1570 wore on, there was a far more sinister figure than Cosimo's blonde bride dominating the minds of the Catholic heads of state. They were increasingly preoccupied with the goal of annihilating the looming menance of the Islamic infidel.

The Battle of Lepanto took place on 7 October 1571 when a fleet of the Holy League, a coalition of southern European Catholic maritime states, decisively defeated the main fleet of the Ottoman Empire in five hours of fighting on the northern edge of the Gulf of Corinth, off western Greece. The Ottoman forces sailing from their naval station in Lepanto met the Holy League forces, which had come from Messina, Sicily, where they had previously gathered. It was the first major Ottoman naval defeat since the fifteenth century, and a huge blow to that empire's prestige. It prevented the Ottoman Empire expanding further along the European side of the Mediterranean.

The struggles against the Ottomans continued, although they would be moved to land with the so-called Long Turkish War, begun in 1594 in the Hungarian border lands.

As preparations for Lepanto got under way, Isabella readied for an event of her own. This was the first time in her life Isabella had carried a pregnancy for more than a few weeks and she became appalled by the changes in her body. In 1571, Isabella's first child was born, a girl named Francesca Eleonora, for both Paolo and Isabella's mothers, but who was immediately called 'Nora' by her own mother.

For a woman who had been so ambivalent about pregnancy and children for so long, the instantaneous bond Isabella had with Nora was notable. She gave birth at the Baroncelli villa outside of the city and although a nurse would have fed the child, Isabella remained with her daughter in the countryside. On 13 September 1572 Isabella finally gave birth to a son, named Virginio.

 

Bianca Cappello was born in 1548, the daughter of Bartolomeo Cappello and Pellegrina Morosini, from one of the richest and noblest Venetian families, and was noted for her great beauty. At the age of fifteen she fell in love with Pietro Bonaventura, a young Florentine clerk in the banking firm of Salviati, and in 1563 escaped with him to Florence. In spite of the birth of a daughter, Pellegrina, her family wanted her back in Venice, and there was the fear that they might abduct her, incarcerate her or even kill her for besmirching the Cappello honour. Pietro, whose uncle back in Venice had been imprisoned in retaliation, had to go about Florence carefully for fear of assassination. With the romance dwindling, Bianca was to prove receptive to outside offers.

​Whatever were the circumstances of the meeting, one thing is certain: Bianca proved to be the only human being to succeed in arousing in Francesco the kind of obsessive devotion he had previously demonstrated only towards the study of chemistry and alchemy.

Although already married, Francesco seduced Bianca and gave her jewels, money and other presents. Bianca's husband was given court employment and consoled himself with other ladies. Brazenly, she made overtures of friendship to a clueless Joanna and, more remarkably, was successful in her attempts. It is difficult to understand how Joanna could not see what was so obvious to everybody else around her. However, the Habsburg princess's obsession with protocol meant she would not countenance being approached uninvited with such news by an inferior at court, and her rather limited Italian meant she did not pick up easily the gossip around her. When Joanna was told who Bianca really was, the revelation served to make her exceedingly unhappy. Her misery had been exacerbated by having gone to Cosimo to protest at Bianca's place at court and being met with little sympathy by the grand duke.

In August 1572 Pietro Buonaventura was murdered in the streets of Florence in consequence of some amorous intrigue, though it is possible that Isabella was involved. She calculated that Bianca as a widow was a much more vulnerable and potentially malleable creature, even as a prince's mistress, than she was a married one. That she had a legal husband was what had largely precluded her Venetian relatives from forcing her back to Venice. Isabella was sure that the potential isolation she faced now would make Bianca Cappello grateful for any prtoection Isabella might offer her.

​Despite Isabella's inability to neutralize Bianca, the period following the birth of her son Virginio was in many ways a very good time for the Medici princess. She continued to play an active role in the lives of her children. They were with her constantly and she spent far more time with them than her own mother had with her. Nora and Virginio's development delighted and fascinated her. In fact, they revealed what would otherwise be a hidden interest and talent of Isabella's, painting.

Early in 1573, Cosimo began to ail; he suffered from lenghty periods of partial paralysis. Mercifully, for someone who had lived with such vigour and energy, the Grand Duke of Tuscany was spared too prolonged an existence in such a state. His health deteriorated further in early April 1572, and towards the end of the month it was public knowledge that his death was imminent.

Francesco was summoned and arrived an hour later, where he carried out his first order of business as the new ruler of Tuscany. Camilla was forced to retire to the Florentine convent of Murate, a strict and severe institution. She was later moved to the convent of Santa Monica. She was allowed to leave the convent only to attend the wedding of her daughter Virginia, on 6 February 1586, with Cesare d'Este, himself the natural son of Alfonso I d'Este, Duke of Ferrara.

In the wake of Cosimo's death, all of Florence was keen to learn how he had distributed the Medici inheritance. The problem was, Cosimo's will had never been formalized, and it was in Francesco's power to carry out Cosimo's wishes as he himself, and not his father, saw fit. Ownership of the Baroncelli villa was in Isabella's name. It was her autonomous possession, so that property should not be contested by Francesco, however irritated he might be that his sister had secured it in the first place. However, Isabella was greatly concerned about her children's welfare and financial future. The Medici had no legal obligation to Nora and Virginio, who bore the name of Orsini and were their father Paolo Giordano's fiscal responsibility, even though they lived in Florence.

Isabella was not the only woman at the Medici court for whom Cosimo's death had brought anxiety, if not downright mysery. Camilla Martelli railed futilely against convent captivity, and Joanna was more tortured than ever before by her humiliation at the hands of Bianca. Isabella's cousin Leonora, married to her brother Pietro, was unhappy too. Cosimo had arranged the marriage in part to keep the charming Leonora in Florence. But he had also perhaps hoped that a bride who had known Pietro since childhood might help with the mental problems he seemed to be facing. An indication of his disturbance occured on the occasion of the official consummation of Pietro and Leonora's marriage.

Given that Pietro was less than physically prepossessing, while Leonora was the acknoweledged young beauty of the Medici court, such unwilligness on Pietro's part to have sexual intercourse with his wife could only be regarded as strange. Pietro's activities with other women are documented, so he clearly had his own reasons for his aversion to Leonora. Nonetheless, in early 1573, Leonora did give birth to a son, whom they named Cosimo and who became known as 'Cosimino'.

Just prior to the birth of his son, Pietro had been appointed General of the Seas of Tuscany, so he was given the naval career that would have been his elder brother Garzia's but for his death in 1562. Pietro embarked on missions that took him away from Florence. During these periods, Leonora spent increasing amounts of time in the company of Isabella, and while Isabella was the chief hostess to her group, Leonora sat at her right hand, praised and admired by those who visited. It was at Isabella's house where Leonora's troubles began to escalate. There was astonishing amount of temptation for a lonely girl in the presence of the array of sympathetic males assembled there, from the pretty pageboys through to their older cavalier brothers. Unlike her husband, they wanted her, to play with her, flirt with her, to go wherever she was prepared to go and willing to listen to whatever she had to say.

Paolo Giordano decided, at the end of May 1576, that he would come to Florence. He took his time getting there and did not appear until the first week of July. If Isabella's June was spent in gloomy contemplation of her husband's imminent arrival to Florence, then her cousin Leonora's was no less troubled. She had had bouts of illness in February and April, and, on 3 June, it was reported that she was very ill from incidents and many doctors say that they were doubtful that she was ill naturally. Florence, then, had its suspicions that the princess was being poisoned.

Leonora di Garzia di Toledo by Alessandro Allori, around 1571

Camilla Martelli by Alessandro Allori

Cosimo I de Medici by Alessandro Allori

Bianca Cappello by Alessandro Allori

Isabella de Medici by Alessandro Allori, around 1571

Pietro de Medici by Santi di Tito, 1584-1586

Bernardino Antinori and his family had long been connected to Isabella's household, and his mother Regina had petitioned Isabella personally to extend her patronage to him in the 1560s. He was a Knight of Santo Stefano who had conducted himself well at the battle of Lepanto but less so in his native city. In February 1576, he had got into a fight with Francesco Ginori, allegedly because both saw themselves as rivals for Leonora's affections. Bernardino was arrested, imprisoned in the Bargello and then subsequently released. He appeared frequently as a courtier in Leonora's coach. Such a public display of flirtation could not go unnoticed, least of all by Francesco de Medici, who was on the lookout for any transgressive behaviour by his sister-in-law. In late June, Bernardino took a trip to the island of Elba, where, invited by Count Lionello delli Oddi, he was, after eating, imprisoned on the order of the Grand Duke. Then, on 9 July, he was strangled at five in the morning in Elba's prison.

In the second week of July 1576, Pietro and Leonora travelled north to the castellated villa of Cafagiollo. Shortly after their arrival, on the morning of 11 July, Pietro sent this short note to his brother Francesco: 'Last night, at seven o'clock, an accident and death came to my wife, so Your Highness can take peace, and write to me about what I should do, if i should come back or not.'

Pietro might have used the word 'accident', but the fact that Leonora's death should bring peace to Francesco is a strong indication that both brothers had known exactly what was to happen to her once she arrived at the villa.

Virgin and Child with St Anne and members of the Medici family as Saints by Giovanni Maria Butteri, 1575

This unusual painting portrays a Holy Conversation, in which members of the grand ducal family represent the various saints. This includes personages who had died some time earlier, such as Eleonora of Toledo who died in 1562, here portrayed as the Virgin, or St Cosmas, interpreted by Grand Duke Cosimo I who died a year before the painting was undertaken. Others were still alive, such as Grand Duke Francesco I who succeeded his father in 1574, here seen as St George, Cardinal Ferdinando is St Damian, and their sister Isabella de Medici is St Catherine of Alexandria.

Just as Leonora had gone to Cafagiollo in the company of Pietro, so too had Isabella gone to Cerreto with her own husband. It’s not known precisely what happened in the summer of 1576 but from contemporary letters, it appears that Paolo Giordano, fed up with Isabella, asked her brother for help in getting her to do her wifely duty. On 16 July Isabella died unexpectedly; according to her brother Francesco this occurred 'while she was washing her hair in the morning. She was found by Paolo on her knees, having immediately fallen dead.' However, the official version of events was not believed and the Ferrarese ambassador, Ercole Cortile, obtained information that Isabella was strangled by her husband in the presence of her servants.

Francesco's vengeance against his sister and her world did not cease with Isabella's death. He turned his attention to arresting those within her circle who had served her. The one whom he was desperate to annihilate was, of course, Troilo Orsini. Of all those individuals associated with Isabella, Troilo was at the top of Francesco's most-wanted list. The problem for Francesco was that Troilo was prey which, unlike Isabella and Leonora, was on the loose. He was not easily trapped and disposed of in a remote country villa, and he continued to elude the Medici grand duke.

Francesco seemed oblivious to the rising anger of the French crown and to Catherine de Medici in particular, who even as late as 1581, four years after the death of Troilo Orsini, declared: 'The Grand Duke does not take account of me, as to the displeasure of myself and the king, and in front of our very eyes he had Troilo Orsini and others killed.' The Florentine response to her protest was: 'Even if the lives of Troilo and the others were taken in your kingdom, what they had done meant they did not deserve life.'  What ensued was a breakdown in diplomatic relations between France and Francesco, which were later repaired when in 1600  Francesco's daughter Maria married Henri IV of the Bourbon line, the former Henri of Navarre. The Valois became extinct in 1589 with the death of Henri III.

In the aftermath of Isabella's death, and perhaps even before, Paolo had fallen in love with the most beautiful woman in Rome, Vittoria Accoramboni. The affair between them set off its own chain of events and even more murders, beginning with that of Vittoria's husband, Francesco Peretti, in order that Paolo Giordano might marry her. The worst aspect of this relationship from the Medici perspective was how Paolo treated his children by Isabella, Nora and Virginio. Paolo did not believe they were his children and it was confirmed not only by his neglect of them but also by the fact that he was prepared to all but disinherit his son. In the aftermath of Paolo's death (in November 1585), Vittoria refused to concede in negotations with Medici family representatives on what she held to be hers.

Not long after (on 22 December 1585), she was stabbed to death by another Orsini family member, Ludovico. However, it was believed that Francesco sponsored the assassination in order to ensure that his nephew got what was his.

In 1578, Bianca achieved the ambition she had long nursed, when the melancholic Joanna died. It was an end to a life in Florence that had been lived largely without joy, although Joanna did briefly see some satisfaction after giving birth in 1577 to a son, Filippo. At least she was spared the pain of the boy's death in 1582. With her dead, Francesco quickly married Bianca and, to Florence's horror, gave to the woman the official title of Grand Duchess, honouring her publicly in a way Cosimo never did Camilla. Later, he legitimized their son Antonio as Medici heir. But even Bianca's triumph was relatively shortlived. In 1587, nine years after her marriage to Francesco, the Grand Duke and Duchess died, just a few days apart, apparently of malaria.

After his brother's demise Ferdinando lost no time in travelling back to Florence from Rome. He divested himself of his cardinal's robe and fully revealed all the cunning that his years as the younger Medici brother had only hinted he possessed. Ferdinando declared Antonio illegitimate and encouraged the doubts that he was Francesco's son at all. He took the grand-ducal crown for himself and a wife in the form of Christina of Lorraine, who proved as fertile as Eleonora di Toledo by bearing him nine children. The very last Medici Grand Duke, Gian Gastone, who died in 1737, was one of Ferdinando's descendants.

Isabella would have been proud of how her children, who continued to be raised in the Medici court, turned out. Virginio took up the Orsini dukedom on his father's death, but having grown up at the Florentine court he was always more Medici than Orsini, spending, by choice, as much time in Florence as Rome. In the autumn of 1600, he arrived at the court of Elizabeth I for an extended stay. This young and gracious nobelman proved popular with his English counterparts. As for Nora, she had her mother's cultural interests and enjoyed composing music. She was married for twenty years to her cousin Alessandro Sforza and bore him numerous children, but it was not a happy marriage. Nonetheless, Nora proved to be a woman of self-conviction and, in 1621, she separated from him and installed herself in a convent of her own founding, a somewhat different response to an unsatisfactory marriage than that of her mother.

Vittoria Accoramboni by Scipione Pulzone

Ferdinando de Medici by Scipione Pulzone, 1590

bottom of page